Explaining Fixed Effects: Random Effects Modeling of Time-Series Cross-Sectional and Panel Data*
نویسندگان
چکیده
T his article challenges Fixed Effects (FE) modeling as the ‘default’ for time-series-crosssectional and panel data. Understanding different within and between effects is crucial when choosing modeling strategies. The downside of Random Effects (RE) modeling— correlated lower-level covariates and higher-level residuals—is omitted-variable bias, solvable with Mundlak’s (1978a) formulation. Consequently, RE can provide everything that FE promises and more, as confirmed by Monte-Carlo simulations, which additionally show problems with Plümper and Troeger’s FE Vector Decomposition method when data are unbalanced. As well as incorporating time-invariant variables, RE models are readily extendable, with random coefficients, cross-level interactions and complex variance functions. We argue not simply for technical solutions to endogeneity, but for the substantive importance of context/heterogeneity, modeled using RE. The implications extend beyond political science to all multilevel datasets. However, omitted variables could still bias estimated higher-level variable effects; as with any model, care is required in interpretation.
منابع مشابه
Explaining Fixed Effects: Random Effects modelling of Time-Series Cross-Sectional and Panel Data
متن کامل
Joint Modeling of Dynamic and Cross-Sectional Heterogeneity: Introducing Hidden Markov Panel Models
Researchers working with panel data sets often face situations where changes in unobserved factors have produced changes in the cross-sectional heterogeneity across time periods. Unfortunately, conventional statistical methods for panel data are based on the assumption that the unobserved cross-sectional heterogeneity is time constant. In this paper, I introduce statistical methods to diagnose ...
متن کاملQML Estimation of Dynamic Panel Data Models with Spatial Errors
We propose quasi maximum likelihood (QML) estimation of dynamic panel models with spatial errors when the cross-sectional dimension n is large and the time dimension T is fixed. We consider both the random effects and fixed effects models and derive the limiting distributions of the QML estimators under different assumptions on the initial observations. We propose a residual-based bootstrap met...
متن کاملFixed and Random Effects in
Received analyses based on stochastic frontier modeling with panel data have relied primarily on results from traditional linear fixed and random effects models. This paper examines extensions of these models that circumvent two important shortcomings of the existing fixed and random effects approaches. The conventional panel data stochastic frontier estimators both assume that technical or cos...
متن کاملSemiparametric Model Selection in Panel Data Models with Deterministic Trends and Cross-Sectional Dependence Jia Chen and Jiti Gao Semiparametric Model Selection in Panel Data Models with Deterministic Trends and Cross-Sectional Dependence
In this paper, we consider a model selection issue in semiparametric panel data models with fixed effects. The modelling framework under investigation can accommodate both nonlinear deterministic trends and cross-sectional dependence. And we consider the so-called “large panels” where both the time series and cross sectional sizes are very large. A penalised profile least squares method with fi...
متن کامل